January 11, 2017 | 4:16 PM

Muslim Girls in Switzerland Must Attend Swim Classes With Boys, Court Says

January 11, 2017 | 4:16 PM
Politics January 11, 2017

In 2008, a couple living in Basel, Switzerland, forbid their young daughters from attending school swim class. The Muslim parents didn’t want their kids, 7 and 9, in the pool with boys.

Officials made some accommodations — the girls could wear burkinis, they said, and they could change without boys present. But they had to come to class.

Still, the parents refused. So the city ordered them to pay a fine of 1,400 Swiss francs (about $1,380) for “acting in breach of their parental duty.” In response, the parents sued, arguing that their right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion had been violated.

The European Court of Human Rights heard their case. This week, it decided that schools can force parents to send their kids to co-ed swimming lessons. It argued that “the full school curriculum” was essential for children’s “successful integration” into society. It also said that the measure “protect[ed] foreign pupils from any form of social exclusion.” And it noted that Switzerland should be able to design its education system according to its particular needs.

“The children’s interest in a full education, thus facilitating their successful social integration according to local customs and mores, prevailed over the parents’ wish to have their children exempted from mixed swimming lessons,” the court said.

The court did acknowledge that religious freedom was being interfered with but said that didn’t make it a violation.

The ruling fits into a much larger debate in Europe, one that pits the religious rights of minorities against a commitment to integration and secularism. In 2013, a German judge ruled that a 13-year-old girl must attend swim lessons but that she had the right to wear a burkini. Last year, France banned women from wearing burkinis in public spaces, a law eventually overturned by French courts. France, Belgium and the Netherlands have each banned, to varying degrees, the wearing of Muslim veils in public. And after two teenage Muslim brothers refused to shake hands with female teachers, Switzerland suspended the family’s citizenship process.

But experts say there’s more at work than simple Islamophobia. Americans tend to privilege the rights of the parent. But in Europe, children have their own rights, ones that the state takes an active role in enforcing. For example, children have a right to an education and an obligation to go to school, no matter what parents say.

The ECHR also believes strongly in protecting the “culture” of particular countries. In 2011, the court found that Italian public schools did not have to remove crucifixes from their walls. In a concurring opinion, one judge explained that to remove the crucifixes would inappropriately curtail Italian “culture.” “A European court should not be called upon to bankrupt centuries of European tradition,” the judge wrote. “No court, certainly not this court, should rob the Italians of part of their cultural personality.”

Sometimes, though, these efforts have enabled the ECHR to uphold some member countries’ more xenophobic legislation, NYU professor Elayne Oliphant said in an email. In 2008, Switzerland banned the construction of minarets through referendum. The ECHR upheld the measure in 2011. In 2014, the court allowed the French ban on Muslims’ full-face coverings to stand, accepting the government’s argument that French culture put a high value on “living together.”

Oliphant writes:

“Such bans or regulations are ostensibly aimed at enforcing ‘integration,’ but instead confirm Muslims’ status as second-class citizens in Europe. That the ECHR has continually supported such efforts in the name of protecting majority ‘cultures’ — which are often equated with the majority religion of Christianity — suggests that the cultural and religious practices of Muslims are simply unworthy of similar protections. At a time when Islamophobia is rampant, the lack of national and European level support for Muslims exacerbates very difficult and painful experiences of exclusion.”

(c) 2017, The Washington Post · Amanda Erickson

#breaking now

  • Trump rally w CREDIT

    Trump in for ‘raw’ conditions when he takes the oath of office

    It’s going to rain on Donald Trump’s parade. About the time Trump raises his right hand Friday at noon…

    C2ZOoWbUQAAhDT_

    SHOCK VIDEO: Nanny Allegedly Burns Kid With Hot Curling Iron

    A Long Island nanny is under arrest after surveillance video captures her allegedly using a hot curling iron to…

    GM General Motors w CREDIT

    NEW: GM to invest $1 billion in US manufacturing

    GM will spend $1 billion to expand vehicle production in the United States, an investment that will allow the…

    C2YnwKdWEAASvI8

    On this day in Earthquake History. Northridge, CA 1/17/94 – M 6.7

    At 4:30 on the morning of January 17, 1994, some 10 million people in the Los Angeles region of…

    [Rhode Island State Police]

    Rhode Island Sisters Kidnapped in 1985 Found Alive in Houston

    Kelly Yates and her sister Kimberly were allegedly abducted by their non-custodial mother, Elaine Carolyn Yates. A felony warrant…

    Breaking News

    Nigerian military jet mistakenly bombs refugee camp, kills more than 100

    A Nigerian military jet has accidentally bombed a refugee camp killing over 100 people.   Among the refugees were…

    Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov listens to a question during his annual roundup news conference summing up his ministry's work in 2016, in Moscow, Russia, Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2017. Lavrov said Russia hopes new U.S. administration will be represented at the Syria talks in Astana, Kazakhstan. (AP Photo/Ivan Sekretarev)

    Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov Says US Tried to Recruit Diplomats

    MOSCOW – U.S. spies under diplomatic cover sneaking along Russia’s borders with Europe. Ten thousand dollars and a recruitment…

    da9e33e44f2c603f27e37d7b8a6d45d9 (1)

    WATCH: Officer Saves Woman And Her Elderly Mother From Burning Car

    A Wadsworth police officer is being recognized for his efforts in helping two women whose vehicle burst into flames…